I see your point regards Fitch, but you have to look at his record since the defeat rather than his total record. Paulo Thiago and Gono is not better than Hardys last two fights of Davis and Swick. ( Note, hes also beaten Gono already )
It's not Fitchs fault the UFC are feeding him back in slowly. He certainly did a job on his last two opponents. If Fitch had Swick as his last win, you can be damn sure I would agree that he deserves the next shot.
As it stands, I would like Hardy or Rumble. Hardy preferably. He's done the rounds and had alot of fights.