If after all of that or if you need a longer term relief you should take a combo of Tylenol (Acetaminophen) for pain relief and Naproxen Sodium, commonly sold as Alieve for inflammation. These medications can be taken together and are not cross-class drugs. One is a NSAID and one is an analgesic pain killer.
Tylenol can also be taken with ibuprofen for the same reason. Tylenol works on the nerves, ibuprofen works on the inflamation. An oral surgeon told me this years ago and I've been doing it ever since. Don't do this on an empty stomach though. You'll pay for it!!