Regarding Renner's badassedness though, did you see The Hurt Locker? That Renner is one of the most badass guys ever imo. I guess I have seen Damon in too many silly roles for Bourne to be totally convincing to me.
Yeah, saw that fairly recently actually. Pretty good film, some great sound effects and suspenseful moments. Interesting character he played too. The character was a real badarse but he was a somewhat unsympathetic one. Too hardcore on the adrenaline junkie business to the point where he would sacrifice his colleagues. That made it hard to identify with the character a bit.