I don't like Crysis games either, or FarCry, nore do I like Assassin's Creed, actaully. I also don't like Halo series, LBP series, I thought Heavy Rain was average at best.
It doesn't have anything to do with the graphics, some games appeal more to others. In fact, it sounds like most of your issues are first person games, "Cry" games, Bioshock, Half-Life 2 - maybe you are sick of FPS games in general. I personally don't like them anymore, the only FPS I plan to get into next is Half-Life 3 whenever that comes out.
As for what I'm playing, I ordered Rapala Pro Fishing 2010 like 5 days ago and it left Phoenix and has reached Union City 2 days back, it's taking forever, I'm hoping an update shows up later today saying it's here or in Eureka, which means it'll be here tomorrow.
You know you like some Team Fortress!
Sent from my iPhone using VerticalSports