I don't think he should be in the HOF. Just because he had such a brief career, and because he was mauled so badly in his last three fights. Sure he ended up winning the Carwin fight but that was more Carwin losing because of his crappy cardio than Brock winning. And his only impressive win in my opinion was the one against Frank Mir. I really didn't find the Herring, Couture, or his first freak show fight that impressive, let alone deserving of a spot in the HOF.