Ummm..., I don't know if that's sarcasm or just very stupid. When 2 of 3 judges think someone won the round, guess what..., THAT SOMEONE WON THE ROUND!!!!
Nope, not in the real world where people use their own brains.
I just realized how dumb that sounds. People using their own brain... what is this? The 1760's?
Even if you're a firm believer in "the judges are always right" there's still a 1/3 chance Bones lost the round. That's statistically significant and basically makes the decision void.