To be honest it doesn't really matter. The win went to Edgar and then Edgar beat up Penn in their second fight. He proved who the better fighter was.
Sent from my iPhone using Verticalsports.com App
It matters to me personally as a fan. I don't have to accept the decision of incompetent judges. You know 1 judge actually scored BJ vs Edgar 1 50-45 in favor of Edgar. Just one example of why I don't take the decision to be law.
Just like I personally feel Creepy and Mouse are 1-1 and there are numerous other examples I could come up with.