You don't have to be a champ to win FOTY, a bunch of lower ranked guys almost won it. It certainly helps though, 3 wins, 1 was supposed to be a loss, the other was a toss up. That's not good enough for FOTY for me. Bones in 2nd place? That's bullshit aswell, Bones fought twice and wasn't as impressive as Anderson.
Andy fought a 205er and Bones fought a 185er.
Andy dominated Chael, Bones beat Rashad.
I don't see how one guy can be no.2 and the other no.9?