MMA Forum - UFC Forums - UFC Results - MMA Videos - View Single Post - Diaz Cites Quebec Commission Irregularities, GSP Should Fight at 170 or Vacate Belt
View Single Post
post #51 of (permalink) Old 03-28-2013, 04:52 PM
Ape City
It's a league game, Smokey
Ape City's Avatar
Join Date: May 2007
Location: Planet of the Apes
Posts: 8,244
Originally Posted by NoYards View Post
Why is that an issue? Commissions are the bodies that set the rules for their jurisdictions. They can make the rules as they see fit, and the fight producers that want to put on fights in those jurisdictions can either abide by those rules, make a request for the commission to apply exceptions to those rules (which the commission can accept or refuse,) or decide not to hold the fights in that jurisdiction.

Commissions can have different rules ... and weight classes vary all over the world

The rules weren't 'relaxed', they were what they have been for a while now .. check out a few weigh in videos for fights held in Montreal, and you will see that they haven't mentioned a non 'right on the lbs mark" weight for a while now .... the rules are different than some other jurisdictions, but that's nothing new. Why is it 'an issue' just because the rules are not the same as "Americans think they should be"?

Here for example is a condensed 6 minute video of the weigh ins for UFC 113, held in Montreal (UFC 158, 154, and 166 have been held in Montreal since then) and unless not a single fighter was a single 0.1 lbs over or under an rounded number, then obviously Montreal has had this rule in place for a while now. (And it certainly wasn't to give GSP any advantage as he wasn't even on the card for this event.)

I find it hard to believe that in at least 4 events, with about 100 fighters being weighed in, that not a single one of them looked down to see that their weight was being rounded off and bothered to check it out... how is that possible?

If Diaz went to Japan to challenge for a WW championship weighing 170lbs, and suddenly found that he was no longer a WW, but actually 2 lbs overweight for the MW class, and was now fighting the LHW Champ who weighted the maximum for LHW at 183 lbs, would he be complaining that the champ should have to vacate his belt just because Diaz didn't know the rules in the jurisdiction he was fighting?
Great post man, this i pretty much where I stand on the issue as well.

The fact that Diaz wasn't informed ahead of time can be blamed on so many people, but in the end I think it falls right on the shoulders of his management. The evidence is in the weigh in videos held in Montreal. Fighters weigh at exactly even weights with no decimal amounts every time from the ones I have seen. Blaming GSP for the way an entire provincial commission has been doing business for years is just crazy.

mad props: Toxic
Ape City is offline  
For the best viewing experience please update your browser to Google Chrome