Against Werdum and JDS, I think he is excused, but did you really brought up a 6 years old split decision against Rothwell?
You know why, his record with the judges
1 split decision win
1 split decision loss
those two wins
Jerry "Scary" Vrbanovic who was 4-4-1 at the time(ended his career 6-7-1)
Shane Ott who was 3-0 at the time (ended at 3-3)
So while I love the dude for finishing 65% of his fights I'm not going to turn the blind eye to that huge hole in his game.