Firstly, there's no way in hell that St. Pierre would beat Chuck. He's a good fighter, but he's not a good enough striker and he couldn't takedown Chuck.
Originally Posted by Cbingham
You guys are so damn swept away by Chuck, he is a nasty mofo but he is no where near invincible. Arlovski or Sylvia and possibly St. Pierre would easily defeat Chucky in an open weight tournament. and I beleive Tito will win if he is granted a title shot at Chuck. his days are numbered
Tito can't compete with Chuck and we saw that at UFC 47 when Chuck dominated tito in the first round and then KO'd him cleanly in the second.
Arlovski and Sylvia could both beat Chuck, but Andrei's not as well versed in boxing and Sylvia's only advantage is his reach. Both of them are great fighters, but Chuck has way more experience than either of them.