Why can't someone be a fan of both jardine & Sherk? Both guys are solid fighters, both guys have had solid fights, both guys are contenders in their own division. They're not bad, at all.
I think Fedor takes this. It won't be easy, but I can see Fedor taking Sylvia down and armbarring him. Big Tim will make him work for it, but still, I see Fedor winning.
They're good, but boring as hell to watch and not at all likable as personalities.