When Serra knocked GSP down and then finished him I just sat there in awe. Not the good kind of awe. The opposite of unexpected boobs.
Another one, although it got no where close to the Tito freakout was when Rampage lost to Forrest via weird judging.
Gonna have to disagree there. Before all the debate started I scored my own card for Forrest, and was actually really surprised there was so much controversy.