wukkadb

Vitor Belfort vs Heath Herring. How did Herring lose that fight? Also, Ninja vs Rampage. BS Decision.

__________________

BloodJunkie

Come on guys! Were talking about the worst decisions ever and nobody has even thought to mention Rob Emerson!

All his decision losses are absolute BULLS**T! I mean WTF! Did the judges even watch those fights?

Judges really piss me off!

Shogun_Is_Champ

Hammill-Bisping Obviously.

Damone

I'm trying to forget those bad decisions. Every time I think about them, things start to break. They screwed Rotten Rob over so much, such a travesty. A TRAVESTY! Rotten Rob Emerson should be undefeated and he would've won TUF 5, but the judges screwed him over.

Also, anyone who thinks Matt Hamill beat Bisping need to watch the second and third rounds.

__________________

ManOfSteel808

gonna have to say Penn vs. GSP...Penn did more damage...

__________________
When in doubt, choke 'em out!

Manx

Matt Hughes vs Carlos Newton 1...
Can't say it was a bad decision, but more like a missed call, as Hughes was out before Newton was...

__________________
Extreme Bias For:
Heath Herring-Josh Barnett-Roxy Modafferi-Kazushi Sakurauba-Murrillo Bustamante-Tatsuya Kawajiri-Megumi Fujii-Dan Henderson-Antonio Rodrigo Nogueria-Kazuyuki Fujita-Hideki Kadowaki

MetalMunkey

I wouldn't say it was controversial. The fight was pretty close depending on how you were judging it, it could have been a split decision for either. I think Penn looking tired and GSP scoring those takedowns are what did it for those 2 judges.

__________________
"You must first believe if you are to achieve. That rhymed... unintentionally."

Favorite MMA Fighters:
BJ "The Prodigy" Penn
Randy "The Natural" Couture

IcemanCometh

I gotta throw out Rampage vs. Lindland and Wandi vs. Hunt...

__________________

Bonnar426

I forgot about Wandy vs. Hunt. Mark had his moments in that fight but no way did he win! If I remember correctly, Wanderlei was throwing punches from top position in the majority of that fight.

Since were on the topic of bad decisions I'm going with Stephan Bonnar vs. Keith Jardine. Blatantly bad decision on the judges part.

Edit: Another one I wanted to throw in there is Alex Stiebling vs Akira Shoji. The only time Shoji was in this fight was when he threw that one punch that knocked Stiebling on his ass. He got top position but then Stiebling was able to reserve it and put a submission on Shoji. Shoji waited out the clock. Third rd it looked like Stiebling was in control of the stand-up. But for some reason two of the judges gave the decision to Shoji.

__________________
You forget that this isn't just some brutal sport where everyones out to kill each other. Its much more like a game of physical chess.-looney liam

All_In

This always bothers me. The eye-poke and the clipping of the nose did all the damage you are referring to. Is that enough to win him the fight when he clearly lost rounds 2 and 3? IMO this one wasn't even close. Even at the end of the first round, BJ is throwing looping hooks and GSP just moves to the side and lands some good jabs.

Rampage vs Lindland and Rampage vs Ninja were ones that didn't seem right to me.

__________________