txtjunkie

ok .. so i want some serious input on this, since no one i know watches mma or cares about it at all really.

i have for years and years and like to consider myself somewhat educated on the topic.

so, id like some input on my p4p top ten and why im an idiot or not etc..


here goes;

1 Anderson "The Spider" Silva
2 Fedor "The Last Emperor" Emelianenko
3 Georges "Rush" St. Pierre
4 Antonio Rodrigo "Minotauro" Nogueira
5 Quinton "Rampage" Jackson
6 B.J. "The Prodigy" Penn
7 Thiago "Pitbull" Alves
8 Kato Kung Lee Sr.
9 Eddie Alvarez
10 Randy "The Natural" Couture


btw .. gsp is my favorite fighter .. but unfortunately i cant possibly rank him higher than those two maniacs

oh, and please mention any fighters i haven't that you think deserve to be in top 10 instead

looking forward to your input =)

Diokhan

replace Rampage with Griffin, he is pretty much undisputed #1 in the world on the most stacked division. Not sure is that supposed to be some sort of p4p ranking or just ranking of general awesomeness, but Griffin should be ranked above Rampage on both. ^^

__________________
"When I land that left hook, the fight will be over." -Paul Daley (He called it!)

txtjunkie

thanks for pointing out that i forgot to point out this was a p4p ranking ..

and about forrest griffin, i guess i was just never really that impressed by any of his fights impirticular. i do agree he is one of the best. i know it sounds stupid since he beat rampage, but rampage's performances have just been more dominating (except vs wandi of coarse) hehe

mmawrestler

I dont believe anyone that has never held a belt belongs in the top ten

Id move bj up to #4
take quinton jackson of the list for now since he lost to forrest and forrest isnt even on the list
take cung lee off

put miguell torres at #5
he is one of the best out there

put big nog at #6 cause he is bignog nuf said
put forrest at #7
Eddie alvarez at #8
Mike Brown at #9
Andrei Arlovski #10


so my list goes

#1-A.silva
#2-Fedor
#3-GSP
#4-Bj penn
#5-miguell toress
#6-Big nog
#7-Forrest
#8-Eddie Alvarez (didnt hold a belt but beat Hansen)
#9- mike brown new fw champ
#10-Arlovski

__________________

TERMINATOR

[quote=Diokhan;730153]replace Rampage with Griffin, he is pretty much undisputed #1 in the world on the most stacked division. Not sure is that supposed to be some sort of p4p ranking or just ranking of general awesomeness, but Griffin should be ranked above Rampage on both.

your list looked pretty good to me. I would take keep griffin off like you have and put in torres and urijah faber. I put faber back in there because everyone loses dosent make him not deserve top ten.

__________________
Grinding Gears

Suizida

Gomi...really?

I got

#1 - GSP/Silva
#3 - Fedor
#4 - BJ
#5 - Nog
#6 - Forrest/Migguel
#8 - Machida
#9 - Alvarez
#10 - Thiago Alvez or Jon Fitch

DJ Syko

Honestly Gomi in the top 10 p4p??? he isnt even a top 10 LW anymore.

here is my list and the true list.

1. Anderson Silva
2. Fedor
3. GSP
4. Torres
5. BJ Penn
6. Minotauro
7. Thiago Alves
8. Sean Sherk
9. Forrest Griffin
10. Urijah Faber

__________________

Royce

Fedor is number 1 any way u look at it.

randy shouldnt be on the list at this point.

BJ should be at 4 or 3..Nogueira should be at a lower place.

and im missing Toress..the guy is a monster.

f**k it..i dont really like P4P lists anyway..

XitUp

You are all wrong.

Robbsville

Rotten Rob takes 1'st.