this is another one that will never happen, but maybe if one leaves chute box it might....i have no clue who would win this fight..today id say silva in a war but in a year or 2 when shogun gets a lil older more mature..he'll be a much better fighter than silva ever was..but even if they faught today shogun would def have a great shot of winning, this is a coin flip in my opinion, everytime silva fights a striker of similar skill he struggles, crocop, hunt, vitor, ect..