First of all. I can't believe I missed these threads.
This is a difficult battle. Spidey could easily crush the Human Torch if he was able to catch him off guard. I mean really he's not going to survive a lamp post to the head or a Jeep thrown at him from a distance. With Peters knowledge of science I really doubt something hot is going to be a major problem. Also, consider his spider-sense and increased agility. Sure, Torch is fast but he has human reflexes and agility so I really don't think he'd ever be able to lay a hand on Peter. Unless of course he decides to level the entire environment.
With that in mind, Torch for the win.
"We are all one." - Genki Sudo