Mixed Martial Arts Forum banner

Should he be inducted to the Hall of Fame in the future?

  • Yes

    Votes: 11 16.9%
  • No

    Votes: 54 83.1%

Does Brock belong in the UFC Hall of Fame?

4K views 49 replies 34 participants last post by  RangerClydeTheBlue 
#1 ·
There are numerous articles out there right now, debating the issue. Some say he does belong in there, others say he doesn't. What does MMAF think? A look at his achievements:

  • UFC record of 4-3
  • UFC Heavyweight Champion
  • 2 Title defenses
  • SOTN award at UFC 116
  • Biggest PPV draw in the history of the UFC

While his record doesn't look so impressive at 4-3, he is still one of the most succesful HW champions of all time with 2 defenses.
 
#33 ·
Almost all his fights in the top 10 most PPV buys ever for the UFC and i think 3 of the top 5 are his fights too. No argument imo, its not just all about records, its also about the impact on the sport and he had the biggest impact out of everyone. Ask any random people on the streets to name MMA/UFC fighters and Brock would be mentioned more than any other fighter, and he is not even in the sport anymore.
 
#35 ·
Brock was brought in as a providential cash cow, just like kimbo slice, but with better luck this time around.

it was a bet and the bet paid and that's the end of it.

now everybody moved on with their lives and everybody's lot richer than before.

I call that a good operation

but certainly nothing worthy of HOF, maybe if there were a "best business move" HOF.


edit: that said, it was fun when he was around, before he found out about the punching in the face issue that happen in those kind of shows. Loved the Brock/Mir Rivalry and the fights, now with some time in between, I actually believe that most of it was staged, including the "coors light incident", that's just very smart promotion, and it did work great. So yea, now thinking about it, still not HOF material, but definitely an era worth remembering. I'd love to see that Fedor/Brock match now, it'd be fun with both fighters retired, probably nothing but balls to the wall back&forth action, they both have good enough technique to make it entertaining. But I think fedor ends up destroying brock in the end. but that's another topic.

so no, well, no HOF for brock, but it was fun to watch nonetheless
 
#36 ·
You can make an argument inducting Brock into the UFC HOF ruins the integrity of the UFC HOF. Is it about athletes or is it about business here? From my understanding the HOF is reserved for athletes who put in their blood, sweat, and tears into the sport and into the business. Brock never came off as that kind of guy, he busted his ass in training, he kicked ass in some of his fights, and he did a couple interviews and primetimes...but for the most part he kept to himself on his Ranch. He brought the UFC a lot of business, and people loved watching him fight, but as far as HOF material goes Brock never sacrificed more than the UFC sacrificed for him, it was an even exchange if you ask me and Brock was treated like royalty basically.
 
#37 ·
I don't think he should be in the HOF. Just because he had such a brief career, and because he was mauled so badly in his last three fights. Sure he ended up winning the Carwin fight but that was more Carwin losing because of his crappy cardio than Brock winning. And his only impressive win in my opinion was the one against Frank Mir. I really didn't find the Herring, Couture, or his first freak show fight that impressive, let alone deserving of a spot in the HOF.
 
This is an older thread, you may not receive a response, and could be reviving an old thread. Please consider creating a new thread.
Top