Meh Chad's either overrated or held down in NY for some unknown reason, I choose the first one.
I would like Favre and his chances in NY. They have a great OLINE now (if their chemistry is good, they definitely have talent - Faneca, Woody, D'Brickashaw), two strong receivers, a great rookie TE, good RB and a way upgraded defense. Butttttt.....Favre will get Madden cursed. I never thought I would believe the Madden curse, but I do now. Let's break it down.
Paranthesis numbers are previous year
2001 - Eddie George - Actually improved stats the next year, but also led to the demise of the Titans in the playoffs when he bobbled his pass that got returned for a TD (the next year was horrible)
2002 - Daunte Culpepper - 2612 (3937) yards, 14 (33) TDs, season ending injury
2003 - Marshall Faulk - 953 (1382) yards, 8 (12) TDs, injured ankle, missed 2 games, started only 10
2004 - Michael Vick - 585 (2936) yards, 4 (16) TDs, fractured fibula
2005 - Ray Lewis - 146 (161) tackles, 0 (6) Interceptions, injured the following year
2006 - Donovan Mcnabb - 2507 (3857) yards, 16 (31) TDs, sports hernia
2007 - Shaun Alexander - 896 (1880) yards, 7 (27 NFL record at the time) TDs, broke foot, now TEAMLESS
2008 - Vince Young - Pass yards improved but... 9 (12) Passing TDs, 17 (13) INTs, 395(552) Rush Yards, 3 (7) Rush TDs
So there you have it...Favre is SCREWED.