So Edgar has no chance of beating Aldo? Silva would have no chance of beating JBJ? GSP can't beat Silva?
With respect, neither Aldo nor GSP is Anderson Silva, and I don't see how that's debatable in terms of anything really: wins, title defenses, stoppages, etc, etc.
GSP would be moving up, not cutting.
Edgar is likely still in the top 5 of most people's P4P list. Evans?
It's one thing to speculate that Rashad might
in a fight against Anderson. But IMO, it's something else again to actually pick Rashad to win the title against a guy like AS in a five-round fight, at a weight class he hasn't competed in.
I do, hoever, want Rashad to make the move to MW, and I suspect his comments here are his attempt at drumming up interest, so it's all good.