As a lot of you said I had 1 and 2 clearly Aldo, and 4 clearly Edgar.
The third round I think Aldo won by a very narrow margin, and in the 5th I think Franie won by a very small margin.
So I have 1-2-3 Aldo and 4-5 Edgar.
I'd have to rewatch the fight tho, since I've only seen it once, and I want to mute the crap out of it, and even use VLC player to slow down the speed and count punches and kicks that landed....only if I have the time or motivation to do it.
1. BJ "The Prodigy" Penn
2. Dan "Hollywood" Henderson
3. George "Rush" St Pierre