Are people really questioning IF Silva deserves a rematch?
He does deserve one, Weidman has continued to say that he expects to give him one, and we all know as sure as hell the UFC wants one. The only person who will stop it is Silva. If he sticks to his message and doesn't take it, then so be it. Who would really think less of him? The man finally has a break and doesn't HAVE to fight because he is defending a belt, he really can pick and choose his fights right now. If he decides tonight that he wants to fight JBJ at UFC 165 I won't doubt that the UFC will tell Gustaffson "Sorry bud, Silva has spoken".
To the point of the thread though, I really doubt the rematch would happen that soon to be honest. Silva wants the time off. I could see it being that Weidman has a title defense before Silva asks for his rematch.