Best P4P fighter IMO comes down to a combination of Talent, Size, and Opponents beaten (Extra points for more recent fights). Fedor is so dominate that he really domiantes rankings but since he is so big it makes it hard to put him at #1. BJ Penn has beaten no one top class in 3 years so I can't put him in the #1 spot. Shogun is a fantastic fighter but is also like Fedor in a Heavier weightclass. Right now I have to go with GSP even though he is not really a WW since he is huge bigger than many MW's. but he is the smallest guy with the great talent and he has the strongest record under 205.
Last edited by bbjd7; 09-04-2007 at 05:30 PM.