Thread Tools

Display Modes

**kds13** · 04-07-2008, 08:45 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Z-man-mma-fan

HW rankings are shit. Nog above Fedor? Fedor has stolen candy from that baby 2 and 1/2 times. Funny and simply pathetic. Crocop isnt in top 10? Kongo in the top 10?

I feel ashamed, i hope everyone skips the HW rankings. I think sherdog has better rankings for that division for God's sakes. The other seems decent.

Edit: Wamma rankings have the right idea. Other than Rothwell imo.

There are logical arguments for everything you just bitched about. Fedor hasn't fought anyone worth sniffing at for 5 years, whereas Nog has continually fought the best his entire career and keeps on winning.

Cro Cop not in the Top 10? Boohoo, why should he be? Because he's had his soul stolen twice recently and tucked his tail between his legs as he ran off to another organization to get some wins under his belt (aka fight cans)?

**chilo** · 04-08-2008, 12:19 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Z-man-mma-fan
HW rankings are shit. Nog above Fedor? Fedor has stolen candy from that baby 2 and 1/2 times. Funny and simply pathetic. Crocop isnt in top 10? Kongo in the top 10?

I feel ashamed, i hope everyone skips the HW rankings. I think sherdog has better rankings for that division for God's sakes. The other seems decent.

Edit: Wamma rankings have the right idea. Other than Rothwell imo.

i have to agree with you there

**chilo** · 04-08-2008, 12:24 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by The Legend

Guys I want to congratulate you again on making the best rankings on the internet, you are even better then MMA writers check this out:

Quote:

Originally Posted by WAMMA
Heavyweight

1 Fedor Emelianenko
2 Randy Couture
3 Antonio Rodrigo Nogueira
4 Josh Barnett
5 Tim Sylvia
6 Andrei Arlovski
7 Fabricio Werdum
8 Gabriel Gonzaga
9 Ben Rothwell
10 Mirko Cro Cop

Light Heavyweight

1 Quinton Jackson
2 Chuck Liddell
3 Forrest Griffin
4 Keith Jardine
5 Lyoto Machida
6 Mauricio Rua
7 Wanderlei Silva
8 Dan Henderson
9 Rashad Evans
10 Thiago Silva

Middleweight

1 Anderson Silva
2 Paulo Filho
3 Rich Franklin
4 Dan Henderson
5 Matt Lindland
6 Yushin Okami
7 Robbie Lawler
8 Nathan Marquardt
9 Kazuo Misaki
10 Yoshihiro Akiyama

Welterweight

1 Georges St. Pierre
2 Jon Fitch
3 Matt Serra
4 Matt Hughes
5 Josh Koscheck
6 Jake Shields (tie)
6 Karo Parisyan (tie)
8 Carlos Condit
9 Diego Sanchez
10 Nick Thompson

Lightweight

1 B.J. Penn
2 Takanori Gomi
3 Gesias Calvancante
4 Sean Sherk
5 Mitsuhiro Ishida
6 Gilbert Melendez
7 Hayato Sakurai
8 Tatsuya Kawajiri
9 Shinya Aoki
10 Vitor Ribeiro

Featherweight

1 Urijah Faber
2 Kid Yamamoto
3 Akitoshi Tamura
4 Jeff Curran
5 Takeshi Inoue
6 Masakazu Imanari
7 Jens Pulver
8 Yoshiro Maeda (tie)
8 Antonio Carvalho (tie)
10 Hatsu Hioki

The WAMMA Ranking Committee is comprised of the most knowledgeable MMA sports/media experts ever assembled. WAMMA has assembled a "Who's Who" of MMA sports/media experts from around the globe.

Source: http://www.gowamma.com/rankings.asp

I like Rothwell and think he has the potential to be a top ten fighter but he isn't right now, and how is Chuck Liddell #2 at LHW? I also don't think Cro Cop should be in the top ten but besides that I guess they are ok but not as good as your guys rankings

IMO that hw ranking looks pretty good.

**cplmac** · 04-08-2008, 04:32 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Z-man-mma-fan

HW rankings are shit. Nog above Fedor? Fedor has stolen candy from that baby 2 and 1/2 times. Funny and simply pathetic. Crocop isnt in top 10? Kongo in the top 10?

I feel ashamed, i hope everyone skips the HW rankings. I think sherdog has better rankings for that division for God's sakes. The other seems decent.

Edit: Wamma rankings have the right idea. Other than Rothwell imo.

There are rankings submitted from about 25 pretty knowledgeable MMA enthusiasts that are combined to form those rankings. There were plenty of voters who agreed with you and plenty who didn't. These rankings are an average and thus the most accurate that can be had. Now if you want to become a member here and get your rankings thrown in the pot that would be excellent. The more people who submit the rankings the more accurate they are.

Biowza · 04-08-2008, 04:55 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Z-man-mma-fan

HW rankings are shit. Nog above Fedor? Fedor has stolen candy from that baby 2 and 1/2 times. Funny and simply pathetic. Crocop isnt in top 10? Kongo in the top 10?

I feel ashamed, i hope everyone skips the HW rankings. I think sherdog has better rankings for that division for God's sakes. The other seems decent.

Edit: Wamma rankings have the right idea. Other than Rothwell imo.

Why shouldn't Kongo be in the top 10?

The Legend · 04-08-2008, 12:11 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by chilo

IMO that hw ranking looks pretty good.

I already said I overreacted but how is Cro Cop and Rothwell top ten heavyweighs? With a win over a top guy Cro Cop can easily get back in though.

AceFranklin88 · 04-08-2008, 08:02 PM

I just wanna know how in the bloody Hell Bisping received a vote(s) at 185...He hasn't fought at 185 yet and he's being voted for. Is that just EXTREME bias? Not a big deal. Other than that, I like these rankings a lot. Very fair.