I may get neg repped for this, but oh well.
If Ken Shamrock was such a clinch for the HOF with his mediocre UFC record (1-4 in his final 5 UFC fights) then to me its not a far stretch to let Evan in. He beat Severn, Kimo 2 times and thats about it. Tanner also 1-4 in his last 5 fights beat Baroni twice, Lawler, Terrell. Both were champs briefly.
Also Evan unlike Ken didn't pull off retarded fits of rage, didn't look like a child who had just soiled himself either, something Ken was known for. Their accomplishments were similar, Tanner had more class.
For that reason, i voted yes. Sorry if i offended any Shamrock fans.