Rashad gets no respect. Some may find him lacking because of his inability to finish his opponents decisvely every fight, but he has so much potential given the right training to become one of the most dominant fighters in the UFC. He looks better with every fight.
Tito's great, but he's not this super versatile fighter people are making him out to be. Rashad would fair very well against him. Rashad has better stand up, and I wouldn't doubt is a better wrestler given his background. he's very agile and flimsy on the ground, which would give Tito trouble I'm sure in keeping control. Tito is a ground and pound specialist. His stand up isn't that great! while Rashad has shown he can hold his own very well on his feet, except his conditioning needs improvement, while Tito's a beast when it comes to conditioning.
So there it is. It wouldn't be this total mismatch as some would assume.