If Nog were a mediocre fighter coming into the UFC then I would agree with you, but he's not. He was without a doubt the #3/#2 Heavyweight in the World. His latest fight against Herring wasn't that bad considering he was nearly out cold and managed to comeback and still win a UD.
What you've done just in the UFC shouldn't matter, what you've done in your entire career should looked at.
Shit, even Lesnar's pro-wrestling career helped him get where he is in MMA.
This Time ... Break It!
FFL Season 3: 11th Place
Quinton Jackson vs. TBA
Gesias Calvancante vs. TBA
Fabricio Werdum vs. TBA
Thales Leites vs. Anderson Silva