View Poll Results: Who wins this "Mock Fantasy Old Style UCF Tourney"

AlphaDawg · 12-02-2009, 09:21 PM

Anyone bragging that a 20-30 lb heavier fighter like Fedor would beat all the fighters lighter than him has no common sense. Clearly he would win, he has an unfair advantage. If him and Anderson Silva ever fight, he would be expected to win because that is his NATURAL weight class. Anderson is natural at 185. Not exactly an accomplishment to beat a smaller fighter.

**khoveraki** · 12-02-2009, 11:19 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by AlphaDawg

Anyone bragging that a 20-30 lb heavier fighter like Fedor would beat all the fighters lighter than him has no common sense. Clearly he would win, he has an unfair advantage. If him and Anderson Silva ever fight, he would be expected to win because that is his NATURAL weight class. Anderson is natural at 185. Not exactly an accomplishment to beat a smaller fighter.

Well, IMO Fedor's frame is a natural 185. The dude's only 6'ish and has a 74" reach, that's like shorter than GSP's reach. He could EASILY cut waterweight to 205 and could definitely cut some chub to 185.

But yeah Fedor takes this. Nobody wants those 2000 credits I offered?

Samborules · 12-03-2009, 07:57 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Davisty69

I'll say it again since nobody responded, why isn't Brock on the list? I really don't like the guy, but you can't argue with his results.

If that answer is that you were trying to avoid the usual Brock vs. all arguments, then so be it. Just curious.

Because I did not want a 280 pd behemoth on this list...only reason.

aerius · 12-03-2009, 09:00 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Terror Kovenant

Fedor vs Silva = 10 seconds into the first round the gateway to Hell opens up and the Four Horsemen tear through the arena as the spectators flee in a panic. Satan via UD.

I'm not so sure about that one.

Fact: Fedor armbarred God as you can see from this picture.

I'm pretty sure he can take on the Four Horsemen and slap an armbar on Satan.

**khoveraki** · 12-03-2009, 03:50 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by aerius

I'm not so sure about that one.

Fact: Fedor armbarred God as you can see from this picture.

I'm pretty sure he can take on the Four Horsemen and slap an armbar on Satan.

Everyone knows Satan's a can. He's been ducking top competition by competing mostly in Hell for all these years. He's dodging top guys like Loke because he's afraid of hurting his legacy.

wado lado · 12-03-2009, 08:39 PM

fedor and anderson in the finals(OMG this would be great)!! fedor wins

Quote:

Well, IMO Fedor's frame is a natural 185. The dude's only 6'ish and has a 74" reach, that's like shorter than GSP's reach. He could EASILY cut waterweight to 205 and could definitely cut some chub to 185.

yes, fedor def is not a natural HW, definitely lighter, and also i think silva is a natural LHW, he just seems huge, like if anyone have seen the video of him and Big Nog boxing, they look the same size

TERMINATOR · 12-03-2009, 08:46 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Samborules

Remember those old style tourneys that made Royce Gracie so famous, you had to win three matches in one day. Imagine it now....Top 8 (all around the same weight..no behemoths or smaller dudes). I included Fedor and Moussasi only because they should be in the UFC?

So here we go

#1) Anderson Silva
#2) Lyoto Machida
#3) Fedor
#4) Shogun Rua
#5) G. Moussasi
#6) D. Henderson
#7) J. Dos Santos
#8) T. Silva

Match #1) A. Silva vs. T. Silva
Match #2) Lyoto Machida vs. J. Dos Santos
Match #3) Fedor vs. Dan Henderson
Match #4) G. Moussasi vs. Shogun Rua

Winners face off and so on...who wins this tourney (presume no injuries)...this is for fun and maybe a start to a good MMA discussion..I know it would NEVER come close to happening in real life...LOL

Anderson beats T silva
Dos Santos beats Machids (JDS to big for machida)
Fedor over Dan (would be close though
Shogun over Mousase

Anderson over JDS
Fedor over Shogun

Fedor over Anderson

Ocelot · 12-04-2009, 12:25 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by khoveraki

First one to name and cite ALL MMA references from my tournament prediction gets 2000 credits donated.

1. fedor's only loss

2. when wandy came in as a replacement for fedor and beat fujita

3. exactly what happened with arona and wandy during the gp.

4. machida's actual fight with thiago followed by what many feel should have happened in the shogun v machida fight

5. Exactly why machida and Anderson don't fight and the last bit was a nod to the leben fight

6. the ko is a ref to gegard's ko by upkicks against souza, and the submission could anderson losing to okami or gegard's triangle on manhoef or kang.

Wheres my 2000?

**khoveraki** · 12-04-2009, 01:24 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Ocelot

Quote:

Originally Posted by khoveraki

Fedor gets eliminated early due to an elbow TKO.

Wanderlei replaces him and beats Brock Lesnar by knees.

Wanderlei is then KO'd by Henderson, who is then KO'd by Shogun.

Machida beats Thiago Silva by KO (I'm going to say, maybe late round 1?), Shogun then beats Machida in a close decision.

JDS and Silva get scheduled to fight but are brazillian training partners, they refuse and JDS is booted from the tournament. Silva then KO's a redhaired midget in an alley somewhere and immediately advances to the finals.

Mousasi then procedes to KO Shogun and submit Silva, both while laying on his backside to win the tournament.

TOURNAMENT WINNER: Mousasi.

1. fedor's only loss

2. when wandy came in as a replacement for fedor and beat fujita

3. exactly what happened with arona and wandy during the gp.

4. machida's actual fight with thiago followed by what many feel should have happened in the shogun v machida fight

5. Exactly why machida and Anderson don't fight and the last bit was a nod to the leben fight

6. the ko is a ref to gegard's ko by upkicks against souza, and the submission could anderson losing to okami or gegard's triangle on manhoef or kang.

Wheres my 2000?

Haha YES! Well done. The only thing you didn't mention is that I used Lesnar because Fujita was a professional wrestler.

Credits donated bro