Originally Posted by Kreed
Okay sure he beat gomi and thomas in their primes but were these guys ever elite?
Now lets flashforward to his 2nd stint at LW which just looks like clean up duty of hasbeens and UFs..He first beats pulver who cant even hang with 145ers in WEC..Then he beats UF journeyman stevenson.. After that its the undersized and ill-equipped sherk, then he beats another TUFer in florian..After that its diego..
With (an undersized LW in) edgar and another TUFer in maynard as future opponents...
My question is BJ penn overated at LW???
your argument lacks one thing: a list of opponents who would beat penn and prove that he is overrated. seriously, who is he overrated, in comparison to? the only people you mentioned so far are that he hasn't beat are edgar and maynard and each of them has a loss to another TUF fighter with multiple losses. Just finding your logic kind of confusing. And I am not even a fan of BJ