Edgar, Maynard, Godzilla..., none of them will beat BJ. I think Maynard would have the better chance because of his size and strength. Edgar is a tiny 155lber. That being said, Edgar has more skills than Maynard, but he is tiny. Penn is a bad matchup for anyone, especially Maynard. If Maynard tried to put his boxing on display with Penn, like he did against Diaz, he would be murdered, no exaggeration. Edgar is too small, he would have to walk thru Penn's boxing to even get close to hitting him, and that will never happen. Neither Edgar nor Maynard has any chance of taking BJ down, but cuz of his size and strength, Maynard has a slightly better chance. Getting a takedown would be the only way either of these 2 could hope to win. Lay and pray. Again, Edgar is too small for that strategy, so he has less of a chance than Maynard, who has 0. Edgar/Penn will be 2 rounds of BJ showcasing his boxing.