The Gomi win is what propelled Guida. At the time Sherk was allegedly going to face him he was 2-2 recently, with wins over Guggerty (cut) and dos Anjos. Remember that most people were picking Gomi to beat Guida, it was that win specifically that put him into title contention.
This is all speculative anyway. Fact: Sherk's biggest win at LW happened five years ago.
Count that he lost to Dunham and he beat Franca on steroids, Sherk's only legit win at LW since 2006 is Tyson Griffin.
He didn't lose to Dunham, your opinion isn't as valid's as the judges, jibbing Sherk because of personal opinion is bullshit and Dunham and G-Sot have not had good 2011's thus far and are pretty far from the title.
Sherk, Guida, Guillard, and Miller are the top guys after Maynard, Edgar, and Pettis.
Always rooting for: Bisping, Shogun, Jon Jones, Daley, Hardy, Sonnen, Fedor, Couture, Jacare.