Originally Posted by Breadfan
It's basically saying that a pound of Fighter A has more fight in it than a pound of Fighter B.
Here's how I view this P4P nonsense.
Imagine a special world where Fighter A (Aldo) can go fight Fighter (B) Lesnar, and In this puff the magic dragon world both fighters weigh In at exactly the same magical 200lbs limit and they both they take their strengts and weaknesses with them.
So, Brock would still curl up like a little girl once Aldo punches him In the face. Thus Aldo Is ranked higher than Lesnar....IMO
Take GSP vs Anderson. I see GSP being STRONGER than Anderson and will use his superior Wrestling and win decisively at the judges. Thus GSP Is above Anderson on MY
People seem to judge P4P on who they have beaten at their respective classes and make a list from that point, which I never quite understood. People In weak division would be ranked much higher than guys In tougher classes. So I always put A vs B when I do these stupid lists.