Wow. Some of you have a pretty broad selection process. This is the Hall of Fame we are talking about. Only a select few glorious fighters should be in there.
Out of that list, only Silva deserves it. GSP is not far away. The rest have done f*uck all.( dont hate... I'm in a theatrical mood ). Sure, some of them are characters that we fans love. I adore some of the dudes listed. But, Hall of Fame should be about outstanding fights and unbeaten runs throughout a whole career. Not the odd magical moment in a mediocre life. Even Tito has looked like shit lately. Silva is 35. Most of these dues were rubbish at 35 if fighting at all. Silva still brings it Yoda style.
It pains me to say this shit, as I particularly love Penn. But he hasnt done enough.