I take it Jon Fitch must be like #100 on the P4P list since his percentage of finishes is god awful, yet only one man has his number.
I thought greatness was based on who you beat, not in the manner in which one is beaten. Randy must also be one of the poorer UFC fighers since that man has been in a lot of decisions, not to mention losses (that man is my hero - Rogan).
Silva has 4 losses, so its not like the man never lost himself. I have Silva #1 and GSP #2 as far as UFC fighters of all time BTW. I still give GSP a very high chance of becoming number 1 since he does have age on his side.
On the subject of Jones, he basically paralleled GSP career, except he won the title while GSP lost to Hughes. Jones has a lot to accomplish before he is in the discussion of greatest. Also I think GSP has not lost since Jones has been in the UFC so its not like GSP has not been doing big things himself.
I would say WW is much deeper than LHW. Machida has only beaten a well past his prime Couture and ppl are saying he will be in line if he beats Davis. That would make Machida 2-2 in his last 4 fights, hardly a title contender in WW.
Last edited by rezin; 08-27-2011 at 10:52 PM.