Originally Posted by HitOrGetHit
Was going to get Thief but everything I r ad is about it being either terrible or massively disappointing.
I have it and think it's pretty great. No idea where all the hate is coming from, to be honest. The mechanics work well and are fun, the stealth is excellent, the graphics are solid, it's a pretty long game if you include the side content (I'm about 8 hours in, only half way through story and tons of side quests to do). If you want a game where you play a thief and the goal of the game is to steal and be stealthy, it does it perfectly.
The only issues I have seen with it is that it can be a little buggy from time to time (nothing game breaking), and the map is hard to read until you get used to it. Also the load times are a bit long (PS4 version, PC probably a lot faster).
Valid problems, but the positives far outweigh the negatives.