Didn't you see the first fight? St. Pierre was inexperienced. Who did he beat before getting that title shot? Karo who only won once before losing to GSP and Jay Hieron isn't anything great. And St. Pierre was dominating Matt Hughes until Hughes got him on the ground and armbarred him, St. Pierre tapped instantly, he only needed one second and could have beaten Hughes in the second. After that fight St. Pierre beat Jason Miller who is a middleweight champion now, Frank Trigg he almost killed, and he beat the heck out of Sean Sherk who took Matt Hughes to the distance. And he also beat BJ Penn, although its debatable who won, I think St. Pierre did more takedowns to win the fight as Penn did more damage. St. Pierre would destroy Hughes in a rematch, plain and simple.