[jdun11]

i dont think there is any question that he should..hes a beast..heres my top 10
1.Shogun Rua
2.Chuck Liddell
3.Wanderlei Silva
4.Ricardo Arona
5.Antonio Rogerio Nogueria
6.Tito Ortiz
7.Rampage Jackson
8.Kevin Randleman
9.Babalu Sobral
10.Allistair Overeem

 

[asskicker]

I dont know I voted no cuz he hasnt done anything lately. But it's close yo could definatly make an arguement.

 

[Choke_Wire]

ya he sould be up there. i would say 9th mabye

 

[jdun11]

technically speaking..Chuck should be #1..but if Shogun didnt have that freak loss to coleman when he fell on his arm ..he would still be the #1 lhw in the world..thats why i put shogun at #1 cuz i dont feel like that was a real loss..if sumthing happened like that to fedor ..we would still consider him unbeatable..its just a freak accident

 

[jdun11]

Chuck has never beat anyone with Shoguns skills..look what rampage did to him..and Shogun beat rampage worse than wanderlei..at least rampage hit wandy..rampage looked so overmatched in that fight..chuck just doesnt look good against guys that can strike..although he beat mezger and overeem, he looked really shaky in both fights..if he got like that against shogun, Shogun would beat his ass worse than rampage did..IM A HUG FAN OF CHUCK, but i truly feel shogun is too well rounded and has too many ways in which to win the fight ..Chucks hope is landing the big shot..I just see chuck getting beat in the striking game against a younger faster and more explsove striker..
in PRIDE Shogun by Ko 7:51 of round 1
in UFC Shogun by KO 4:23 of round 2

 

[pt447]

shy should he be? what is his record? how well does he perform? he's a roid-raged freak who has never shown an ounce of fighting skill... he's just a beast who tries to overpower guys and then lays on them... ooh, real fun!

 

[pt447]

why should he be? what is his record? how well does he perform? he's a roid-raged freak who has never shown an ounce of fighting skill... he's just a beast who tries to overpower guys and then lays on them... ooh, real fun!

 

[moldy]

number one id to tough. Wand and chuck haven't fought. i'd say it's between them. Randlman shouldn't be in that list. Sakuraba, mirko, waterman, fedor, and rampage have all beaten him. he's 2 for 8 and i don't count that flucky KO he got on cropcop as a win. And the other was against Fatih Kocamis. Check his profile he is 8-8-1 and it was by Decision. I don't think he ranks up there. I think they are using him cause he is a american name. And why not have a big american name get his [email protected]# beat by a pride fighter in america.

 

[GSPFAN]

I think Randleman should be ranked in the top ten light heavyweights because he is fighting the top heavyweights and light heavyweights all the time. He even beat one of the best heavyweights ever in my opinion (Bas Rutten) and he beat Pete Williams who was good at the time for a heavyweight. Plus he beat Crocop which was amazing and almost KOd Fedor. I think he deserves to be ranked in the top 10. I just think that Alistair should not be for repeatedly losing, not proving himself in the ring and Forrest Griffin deserves to be in it way more than him even Kazuhiro Nakamura does.

He did not win that fight.

 

[WandyBJPenn]

number one id to tough. Wand and chuck haven't fought. i'd say it's between them. Randlman shouldn't be in that list. Sakuraba, mirko, waterman, fedor, and rampage have all beaten him. he's 2 for 8 and i don't count that flucky KO he got on cropcop as a win. And the other was against Fatih Kocamis. Check his profile he is 8-8-1 and it was by Decision. I don't think he ranks up there. I think they are using him cause he is a american name. And why not have a big american name get his [email protected]# beat by a pride fighter in america.

I don't think that KO was luck, because Cro Cop overlooked Randleman thinking he was gonna wait to catch him with that LHK, and Randleman caught him. I wouldn't put Randleman up there, but I would give him honorable mention because of what he did to Cro cop, that no one has really done, and what he almost did to Fedor. That slam is classic!